Dr. Susan Michell - Nutrition Expert Dr. Susan Mitchell Nutrition Expert
home about services media clients Contact

April 14, 2010

Got Milk? Is it Raw or Pasteurized? Part 2

april-blogWith the trend towards locally grown, eco-friendly, natural food, raw milk is touted as being more healthful, better tasting and nutritious than pasteurized milk…but is it? Proponents of raw milk say it’s safe to drink…but should you drink it and give it to your family

Raw milk is milk that has not been pasteurized. It’s milk from any hoofed animal including cows, sheep or goats. Because of the potential for raw milk to contain a wide variety of bacteria including such suspects as:

  • Salmonella
  • E. coli
  • Listeria
  • M. tuberculosis
  • Campylobacter
  • Brucella

Public health officials for decades have expressed concern over drinking raw milk. Symptoms of illness range from:

  • vomiting
  • diarrhea
  • abdominal pain
  • fever, headache and body aches

However, people with weakened immune systems from HIV or autoimmune diseases or infants, young children, pregnant women and the elderly are especially sensitive and illness from raw milk can be very serious and result in death.

Joining me on the podcast to answer more questions about the raw milk movement is Dr. Ronald Schmidt, Professor of Food Science and Human Nutrition at the University of Florida. Dr. Schmidt has authored more than 100 scientific publications and presentations in dairy/food science technology, food safety, and microbiology, and is co-editor of the book, Food Safety Handbook.

Dr. Schmidt delves into these questions that you have asked?

  1. First, I have to ask this same question that I asked Joe Wright, the dairy farmer who was our guest last week. Do you drink raw milk or pasteurized milk and why?
  2. Proponents of raw milk say it is more nutritious with additional enzymes and healthy bacteria that are destroyed by pasteurization. Is one milk more nutritious than the other?
  3. Does raw milk contain antimicrobial components making pasteurization unnecessary? What effect does pasteurization have on milk?
  4. Dr. Schmidt, advocates of raw milk point to some studies where children drinking raw milk have less allergies, asthma and eczema. Where does the scientific community come out on this debate on drinking raw milk and giving it to children?
  5. What about cheese made from raw milk? Is it safe? I see dairies selling it at farmers’ markets.
  6. Do you think raw milk will become legal in Florida and other states?

What’s your opinion on raw milk? Post your comment on my blog and I’ll share some of them on an upcoming podcast.

Listen to this week’s podcast


April 7, 2010

Got Milk? Is it Raw or Pasteurized? Part 1

dairy farmer Joe Wright

dairy farmer Joe Wright

Raw milk is touted as being more nutritious than pasteurized milk…but is it? Proponents of raw milk say it’s safe to drink…but should you drink it and give it to your family?

You don’t want to miss this week’s podcast.  I dig into the questions about raw milk that you have asked and get answers from dairy farmer Joe Wright. Questions such as:

  • Joe…you’re a dairy farmer. Do you drink raw milk or pasteurized milk and why?
  • There is a large underground market for raw milk with people selling it as pet food yet humans consume it. Would you explain this?
  • Some farmers sell both raw milk and pasteurized milk…is that correct?
  • Can you really insure that raw milk or cheese made from raw milk is pathogen-free?

Joe has traveled a very interesting path from the firm to the farm. He grew up in Florida and attended the University of Florida law school. Ok, so I went to The University of Tennessee and he IS a gator…but I won’t hold that against him. While practicing law specializing in health care, he met his wife, the daughter of a dairy farmer. The rest, as they say, is history.

After spending time working with his father-in-law on the farm, he knew he could never go back to an office. Passionate about dairy farmers and active in their industry, Joe serves as first vice president of Dairy Farmers, Inc., Florida’s milk promotion group.

Raw milk has been making headlines lately from proponents who feel it’s not only safe to drink but boosts the immune system and shouldn’t be banned. On the flip side were reports in the media last week of an outbreak of campylobacteriosis in Michigan from raw milk with symptoms of diarrhea, fever and abdominal pain.

If you ask 10 people if raw milk is safe to drink, you would probably get 10 different responses. So today and next week we’re delving in to what the evidence-based science says about raw milk and whether it’s safe to drink or a setup for illness which could be potentially deadly.

Listen to this week’s podcast


Featuring Advanced Search Functions plugin by YD

Dr. Susan Mitchell's Blog